Categories: Știri

France's nuclear capability offers fringe benefits to allies

„To be free one must be feared,” Macron said, „and to be feared one must be powerful.”

France’s president has determined that his country, one of only two European nations with nuclear strike capabilities — called the „force de frappe” — is more powerful when it spreads its umbrella a bit further to cover allies Paris considers part of its „vital interests.”

In addition to the ever-present threat from Russia’s nuclear saber-rattling, what Macron called the Trump administration’s „resetting of priorities” is a „strong incentive for Europe to take more direct control of its own security…. of our own destiny.”

„The world has become tougher and this has been further demonstrated by events of the past few hours,” Macron said, referencing the escalating violence in the Middle East. „In keeping with our national and European challenges, we have to strengthen our nuclear deterrent… We must think of our nuclear deterrent on a European scale.”

What changes and what doesn’t in French nuclear policy

While Macron said France will increase its stockpile from around 290 warheads, it will no longer be transparent about that number. All nuclear moves would be coordinated with and complementary to NATO’s own nuclear deterrent, Macron emphasized. But: There will be no consideration of sharing the decision-making over the use of the French stockpile, the president stressed many times, nor a US/NATO-style „nuclear sharing” arrangement where weapons would be stationed in other countries and to a large extent dependent on cooperation.

He said the coordination with NATO will be an additional deterrent to the alliance’s own nuclear program. France does not participate in nuclear NATO activities.

But as part of what he called „advanced deterrence”, he did announce the possibilities of temporarily stationing French nuclear-capable aircraft in other countries, of holding multi-national nuclear-related exercises and of hosting visits to French nuclear facilities. He said in addition to the UK, Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands will participate. Swedish Prime Minister Ulf Kristersson issued a statement with his Danish counterpart Mette Frederiksen to announce Sweden is also signing on.

Germany goes first

Coordinated with Macron’s announcement in the speech that Germany would be the first key partner after the UK, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz posted on X about the increased cooperation, which will include joint military exercises and the development of further capabilities in early-warning systems, air defense and deep strikes.

Claudia Major, Senior Vice President for Transatlantic Security at the German Marshall Fund of the United States (GMF), called the bilateral deal „groundbreaking.”

„Five years ago we had an election campaign [in Germany] which was about getting rid of nuclear weapons,” she told DW, „and now Germany is one of the leading countries in doing the nuclear cooperation with France. So, the synchronization of the bilateral relationship is amazing.”

Major said Macron’s effort to remain „so NATO-friendly” in his approach is what makes it possible for Merz and the other leaders to participate without suggesting they want to replace the US umbrella and nuclear-sharing arrangements.

At the same time, Major underscores the unquestionable grip French leaders will keep on their nuclear button.

French President Emmanuel Macron and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz released a joint statement pledging closer cooperation on nuclear deterrence just as Macron was giving his speechImage: Embassy of France in the U.S./X

„They will never compromise on the autonomy, never on the sovereign nature of the chain of command,” she said.

‘Advanced deterrence’ goes further than expected

Darya Dolzikova, a senior research fellow for proliferation and nuclear policy at the Royal United Services Institute, says she was surprised by how collaborative the French proposals are, echoing Major’s emphasis on the French insistence on full sovereignty over their arsenal.

Vezi mai multe articole.

„I was tempering my expectations in terms of how much more clarity we would get or how forward-leaning Macron would be on the ‘European dimension’ of the French nuclear deterrent,” Dolzikova told DW.

She said that particularly the potential deployment of French nuclear-capable systems to allies’ territory and bilateral planning with other European governments „does open up the door to much closer coordination with allies on nuclear issues than I expected the French to be ready for.”

Dolzikova, who’s recently published research urging Europe to review its nuclear posture due to uncertainty over US security guarantees, notes that the new approach by Macron is more than just empty words and indicates a conscientious upgrade of his commitment to French allies.

„A deployment of strategic systems further east into Europe also raises the risks that France could get pulled into a conflict in Europe early if those systems are attacked,” she explained. „It is a commendable step forward by the French in showing their willingness to take serious responsibility for European security.”

Vezi si servicii IT externalizate.

New plans unpopular among Swedish opposition

Not everyone is impressed. Sweden became a staunch advocate of nuclear disarmament after abandoning its own covert research program into nuclear arms which ran from 1945 to 1968. Now Swedish Green Party politicians are speaking out against extending the nuclear umbrella to the Nordic state, suggesting this is pulling Sweden into an arms race. The Green Party is currently in the opposition in Sweden

Macron’s speech comes just days after the French aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle, which is capable of carrying nuclear weapons deployed by Rafale fighter aircraft, visited Sweden amid great fanfare by government officials on both sides.

NATO’s nuclear doctrine was a matter of debate during the run-up to Sweden’s alliance membership, with the government stating it „would not host nuclear weapons on Swedish soil during peacetime.”

While that doesn’t change by drawing closer to France, Green Party spokesman Daniel Hellden tells DW that expanding nuclear arsenals, as France intends to do, „will not make Europe safer.”

„We should focus on strengthening our conventional capabilities,” he said, „and build strong robust societies that become deterrents in and of themselves.”